Sunday, November 15, 2009

My adventures with sourdough

I decided to try making sourdough bread after reading about a recipe on the blog, My Sister's Kitchen. The recipe describes making a huge loaf of bread, so for my first time I halved it. I cooked it in my larger CorningWare dish (4L), but it turned out to be a very flat loaf because the dough was a little too small for the dish. Still tasted delicious though! The sourdough taste was good, but my friends who tasted it remarked wasn't very strong.

For my second attempt, I made the whole recipe and used my smaller CW dish (2.8L). The sourdough taste seemed stronger, although I don't know enough about bread making to know what I did differently. The crust is crispy, chewy and just the right amount of toughness.


Here is the recipe reproduced with pictures and my own notes. Click the link above for the original blog page and recipe.


First, the starter. I used the
natural sourdough starter method from the blog. Couldn't be easier. I didn't throw away half the starter each time I fed it as per instructions though, because I wanted to build up the quantity. I have a bowl on the counter that had about 2 cups of starter in it before I made the bread. I do pour off the grayish clear liquid (the liquor) every day. I guess that I have been letting the starter brew for about two weeks.

6:30-ish PM, Saturday

Mixed the dough.


  • 1 c. sourdough starter (if you weigh ingredients, this will be 9 ounces)
  • generous 1/2 t. yeast
  • 2 t. salt (Clair only uses 1 1/4, but I take it up to 2 t. because it gives me the flavor I’m looking for)
  • 1/2 t. sugar
  • 6 cups of flour
  • 3 c. lukewarm water

Start by stirring a slightly rounded 1/2 t. yeast and 1/2 t. sugar into two cups of warm water. Put aside while you stir together the other dry ingredients. The yeast will dissolve almost immediately and start to grow. Into the dry ingredients, stir the yeasty water, a third cup of warm water and the cup of starter. Stir enough to mix all these things completely, but this stirring isn’t meant to knead the bread at all. You’ll end up with a very wet, sticky mixture.
Cover the bowl with plastic wrap and set on the counter for 12-18 hours. (Yes, that reads HOURS.)

I mixed it in a large glass mixing bowl, and it was very full. I knew from my first halved recipe that this dough would rise very large, and I knew if I left it in the bowl, it would be all over my counter. So I put it in a big pot for the rising portion.

3:40-ish AM, Sunday
See how huge it gets?

12:15-ish PM, Sunday

After 12-18 hours (all right, I did get impatient a few times this week and did this step at ten hours with no ill effects) turn out the bubbly, fluffy dough onto a well-floured counter. Fold the dough over on itself once or twice. Again, you’re not kneading this dough at all. The long rise-time is actually doing the same thing that kneading would do: developing the gluten fibers. Let the dough rest on the counter for 15 minutes.

After 15 minutes of resting, plop the dough on a lint-free towel that has a layer of either coarsely ground cornmeal, wheat germ, bran, or rolled oats. Sprinkle more of whatever grain you’re using on the top. The dough will be VERY hard to handle because it is so slack and sticky. Do your best.

Well, I don't have the right towels, so I just floured a cookie sheet and turned the dough out onto that.
I turned it over on itself a few times with a wooden spoon. Fairly easy, since you're not trying to really knead it with your hands or anything. The dough is, as the blog describes, very sticky and slack. I covered it with more flour and the plastic wrap.

2:30-ish PM, Sunday

Cover the dough with a second towel and let rise on the counter another 2-3 hours.


3:15-ish PM, Sunday

Thirty minutes before you plan to bake the bread, turn the oven on to 450° and put the pan that you plan to use into the oven to preheat. Let pan and oven preheat for 30 minutes. Yesterday someone asked me if a full 30 minutes was necessary. It probably isn’t, but there are two things that you want: a pan that is completely heated through before you put the dough into it and an oven that is completely heated to 450° with no possibility of cooler spots in parts of the oven.

A word about what pan to use. Clair used two cast iron dutch ovens (which means that after the 12 hour rise, she divided the dough into two balls.) I’ve been using an enormous 8 quart cast iron dutch oven that makes a humongous loaf. This method requires a LID for whatever pan you use. The lid is very important. I’ve also used two of my heavy Calphalon saucepans as well as a couple of my pyrex casserole dishes. The pan should be heavy. Like I said, a lid is essential.

As mentioned above, I used a 2.8L CorningWare casserole type dish with a glass lid.


The dish was pretty full and I was a little worried that with the lid on, it would keep the bread from rising it's full height.

When it’s time to bake the bread, gently slide the dough into the hot pan and put the cover on. Put the pan back into the oven for 30 minutes at 450°... Remove the lid and bake uncovered for another 15 minutes.

It doesn't seem squished, and the "crumb" is great, not too dense or anything. So I think it worked out OK.
Remove from the oven and turn out the loaf onto a rack immediately.
The picture doesn't do it justice. It's a much more lovely golden brown than this shows. And it tastes amazing. I never thought I could bake bread, much less a sourdough. It always seemed so intimidating. This recipe is so easy, anyone can do this!

Many thanks to the ladies of My Sister's Kitchen! It's a great blog with many tasty recipes; go check it out!